Choosing a Sunscreen and Top picks for 2024

by Ali Anne Johnson & Kris Francefort

When choosing a sunscreen, it’s important to be aware of certain ingredients that may pose health concerns. Just as you read food labels, it’s important to read labels on the products you put on your skin.

Also consider avoiding sunscreens that pose environmental concerns. Many common sunscreens are known to cause coral bleaching and harm marine life and ecosystems leading to restrictions and bans in some locations. If it harms marine life, it harms you!

Here are some ingredients to avoid:

  • Oxy/Avo benzone, Octinoxate, and Octocrylene: Linked to hormone disruption and allergic reactions. They can penetrate the skin, cause skin irritation and enter the bloodstream. They are also potential carcinogens, but more research is needed.
  • Retinyl Palmitate (Vitamin A Palmitate): This ingredient can increase skin sensitivity to the sun and may accelerate the development of skin tumors and lesions when exposed to sunlight.
  • Parabens (Methylparaben, Propylparaben, etc.): Parabens are preservatives that can disrupt hormone function and are associated with reproductive toxicity and breast cancer.
  • Phthalates: Often used to enhance fragrance, phthalates are endocrine disruptors linked to hormone, reproductive and developmental issues.
  • Fragrance: Undisclosed mystery ingredients that can cause skin irritation, allergic reactions, and may contain harmful chemicals like phthalates.
  • Homosalate: This UV filter can accumulate in the body and disrupt hormones. It may also cause skin irritation.
  • Propellants: Associated with aerosol based sunscreen that may contain butane.

Sunscreen Marketing

Don’t be fooled by marketing on sun care products. Due to the attention on sunscreens and their effect on the environment many products will say “Reef Safe” or “Paraben Free” as they don’t contain chemicals directly related to causing harm, however they still contain some chemicals that may be toxic. For instance oxybezone is know to be toxic to reefs so it has been replaced by avobezone which a growing body of research has suggested may actually be harmful to reefs.

What are the best sunscreens?

The best are non-nano mineral sunscreens that are zinc oxide based. Also look for European or Korean sunscreens that contain Tinosorb S or Tinosorb M. They are high quality chemical sunscreen ingredients with the best broad spectrum coverage and blend perfectly into the skin with zero white cast.

When selecting a sunscreen, consider your specific needs, such as skin type, any skin conditions, and the activities you’ll be doing. It’s also important to apply sunscreen correctly and reapply every two hours, or more frequently if swimming or sweating, to ensure maximum protection.

Don’t stress about always having quality

If you are out and about, don’t have access to your preferred mineral sunscreen, and you know you’ll be in the sun for a prolonged period of time, just use a conventional, chemical sunscreen.

While we are not a fan of these for the reasons stated above, an occasional use is unlikely to have any meaningful impact, and we do know that there can be lasting impact from serious burns.


Recommendations from Lara Adler, Environmental Toxins Expert:

Stream2Sea SPF 20 sunscreen

Stream2Sea SPF 20
This is my go-to sunscreen in the summer. Stream2Sea is one of my all time favorite product lines that’s safe for people and the environment!
Cocokind daily spf bottle
Cocokind SPF
This is my go-to sunscreen all year round! The first time I tried Cocokind’s SPF, I knew it was going to be a game changer for me and so many others. It’s not greasy and it blends in well with all skin tones.
annmarie skincare sun love sunscreen bottle
Annmarie Sun Love SPF 20
This very light-weight (and barely tinted) sunscreen works wonders! Although everyone’s skin behaves differently, it’s formulated to work with every skin type and has a subtle tint to it which offsets some of the white cast that you get with mineral sunscreens.
Suntegrity sunscreen orange tube
Suntegrity SPF 30
A very popular sunscreen on EWG, Suntegrity has a smooth formula with a relatively light texture compared to most mineral sunscreens. That said, this does leave a very heavy white cast upon application but it usually goes away once it settles into the skin.
juice beauty brand sunscreen tube
Juice Beauty Oil-Free SPF Moisturizer
This is one of the best sunscreens for everyday use. It’s ideal for all skin types but is especially great for those with sensitive skin! It’s very hydrating but doesn’t feel like an oil slick on your face.
yellow babo botanicals sunscreen tube
Babo Sunscreen
This sunscreen is MadeSafe Certified, and uses uses the right amount of zinc oxide to offer the best sun protection.
EleVen Unrivaled Sun Serum
EleVen Unrivaled Sun Serum
This lightweight serum sunscreen combines skincare and mineral sun protection. Designed by Venus Williams for people with darker skin tones and doesn’t leave a white cast!
Beautycounter Countersun tube
Beautycounter Countersun
Beautycounter’s SPF is super popular for a reason: it works well on many different skin types and skin tones! It’s very hydrating and has a skin-like dewy finish.
MyChelle Sun Shield tube
MyChelle Sun Shield
MyChelle makes some really reliable and accessible products — this SPF is just one of them! This SPF is especially great for sensitive skin and will work for most skin types. Can also be found at your local natural foods store.
Goddess Garden Everyday Sunscreen
Goddess Garden has several sunscreens in their line but this one is probably the most versatile. It works as an everyday sunscreen or for more active days outside.

For additional skin care and other product recommendations from Lara, go to her website. Please note that Lara will receive an affiliate reward if you choose to purchase by clicking any of the “buy now” links above.

Image by Mikhail Nilov at Pexels.com

Like this post? Sign up for more

PLUS get instant access to our FREE seasonal magazine by entering your name and email below.

Leave a Reply